Read the referee report (PDF) · GitHub repository ↗
My report
The paper by Moreno-Medina, Ouss, Bayer and Ba measures obfuscatory language in US news reports on police killings and relates it to support for the police. In my report, I argue that their evidence shows a correlation between police and media language rather than police reports driving media coverage, and I suggest an analysis of evidential markers such as “police say” to test it. I also question the donation outcome used in their experiment, propose the CES panel to account for respondents’ media exposure, and point to other differences across media outlets worth examining.
About this work
Course team: Antoine Ferey, Roberto Galbiati, and Franz Ostrizek. Course syllabus.